Ever since it came out in 2015 I've been a big fan of the adaptation of Far From the Madding Crowd by director Thomas Vinterberg. In my opinion it is one of the most underappreciated films of the last decade and I only love it more with each rewatch (I gave it only a B+ on my initial watch but it has only grown in my estimation since.) That said, I was always told that it really isn't that great when compared with the 1967 version by director John Schlesinger. This is why I added the classic film to this year's blind spot selections. Now I have seen both films and... I still like the 2015 film better! In basically every regard I think the 2015 film is superior to the 1967 classic. 
Since this is a review of the 1967 film let's talk about that version first. Schlesinger has made a beautiful film that feels right at home with the epic brand of storytelling popular at the time. There are many stunning sequences such as the fire being on hay and the devastating suicide of the sheep. They also have a talented cast with Julie Christie, Terence Stamp and Alan Bates.
The movie does take its time having every detail from the book such as an extended sequence when Troy is at the circus and more time between Boldwood and Bathsheba. Modern viewers will be surprised by the amount of time focused on Troy instead of Gabriel, who is more of an after thought in this version. We are supposed to buy that Troy is both in love with Fannie that he makes life miserable for everyone else but also so prideful that he rejects her after she goes to the wrong chapel for their wedding. This makes for a difficult and unlikable character to have as your lead for a 3 hour movie.
I personally love the approach by Vinterberg much more. By focusing on Gabriel and his long-seated love for Bathsheba we have a great love story instead of depressing melodrama. It also doesn't hurt that Carey Mulligan and Matthias Schoenearts have incredible chemistry and they keep this friends-to-lovers story simmering for the much shorter 2 hour runtime. I see little in the additional hour of the 1967 film to justify so much more time especially with the characters they chose to focus on.
2015's Far From the Madding Crowd is also beautifully filmed by Charlotte Bruus Christensen giving everything a hopeful energy especially when combined with Craig Armstrong's stirring score. It makes for an overall moving journey we just don't get in the 1967 film. The earlier movie may be more accurate to the book but where's the heart and soul? I'd take the 2015 version any day!
I wouldn't say the 1967 version of Far From the Madding Crowd is a bad movie. It's serviceable. I just like the 2015 much better!
No comments:
Post a Comment